The5For

Imagine the sweet symphony of happy customers, the satisfying ring of the cash register, and the undeniable buzz around a convenience store. That’s the potential National Ice Cream Day holds for owner/operators. This isn’t just another date on the calendar; it is a presidential proclamation, a beloved tradition, and a prime opportunity for c-store owners to truly shine. Americans consume a remarkable 23 gallons of ice cream a year, and over 90% of the U.S. population enjoys this frozen delight, making it a universal crowd-pleaser. The fact that a U.S. President officially proclaimed this day, and that it has been celebrated annually since 1984, elevates it from a mere marketing opportunity to a significant cultural event. This deepens its relevance and resonance with consumers, making promotions feel less like a sales pitch and more like participation in a cherished tradition. For a convenience store, tapping into this cultural significance means higher consumer receptivity and engagement, as customers are already predisposed to celebrate. It is not about convincing them to buy ice cream but about facilitating their participation in a national celebration.

This approach is not about just stocking more ice cream; it is about strategic moves that will boost engagement and sales. The following sections will delve into five main strategies that can help capitalize on this deliciously lucrative day, turning casual shoppers into loyal fans and boosting the bottom line.

1. Craft Irresistible Promotions and Deals

This strategy involves designing special, enticing offers and discounts specifically for National Ice Cream Day to attract customers and encourage them to spend more. It is about creating a sense of urgency and excitement around the ice cream offerings.

Special promotions are a direct magnet for foot traffic, drawing customers into a store who might not have otherwise visited. Once inside, these deals encourage impulse purchases, especially when ice cream is strategically placed. They also generate buzz, making a store a talked-about destination for the holiday. By offering perceived value, the purchase decision becomes easier and more appealing, leading to higher transaction volumes and potentially larger basket sizes as customers add complementary items.

Leveraging a nationally recognized holiday like National Ice Cream Day with targeted promotions maximizes marketing efforts, as consumers are already in a celebratory mood and actively looking for deals. This is a golden opportunity to attract new customers who are deal-seeking or simply celebrating the day, and to reward existing loyal customers, reinforcing their positive association with the brand. It also allows a store to stand out from competitors who might not be as proactive. Promotions that incorporate elements of scarcity (limited time, limited quantity) or novelty (unique eligibility, creative mechanics) generate disproportionately higher levels of customer engagement, social media buzz, and free publicity compared to generic discounts. This is because they tap into psychological triggers like the Fear Of Missing Out (FOMO) and the desire for unique experiences, transforming a transactional offer into a memorable event. This approach can lead to enhanced brand visibility and a stronger, more positive association with fun and innovation.

Here is how to implement this strategy:

• Offer specific, eye-catching discounts:
  • Consider “$1 Scoops” or “$2 Cones” during a specific “happy hour” window on July 20th.
  • Implement “Buy One Get One Free” (BOGO) deals on pints or novelty items.⁵ For example, Bubbies Ice Cream and Whole Foods offered a BOGO on all Bubbies products.
  • Provide a “Free Dilly Bar with any $1 purchase” for loyalty members, as Dairy Queen did.
• Create tempting bundle deals:
  • Pair ice cream pints with complementary items like cones, toppings (chocolate syrup, sprinkles, cherries), or even whipped cream for a “DIY Sundae Kit”.
  • Offer a discount when customers buy an ice cream and a cold beverage together.
• Run limited-time or unique offers:
  • Host a “Free Mini Cup” giveaway for the first 100 customers during a two-hour window, as Dippin’ Dots did. This creates urgency and excitement.
  • Explore creative, name-based promotions like Halo Top’s offer of free pints for people whose names matched iconic ice cream brands. This can generate significant media buzz and social sharing.
  • Introduce a “Month of the Sundaes” where a new fancy sundae is released each Sunday in July, with a discount on the release day.
• Utilize digital coupons and app-based promotions:
  • Promote exclusive deals through the store’s app or a loyalty program.⁵ For instance, Baskin-Robbins Rewards members received $5 off orders of $20 or more through third-party delivery.
  • Offer bonus points for ice cream purchases on National Ice Cream Day for loyalty program members.

2. Master the Art of Merchandising and Display

This strategy focuses on optimizing the visual presentation, strategic placement, and proper storage conditions of ice cream products within the store to maximize their appeal and accessibility.

An enticing display immediately catches the customer’s eye, making the ice cream hard to miss. Strategic placement near high-traffic areas or checkout counters directly triggers impulse purchases, turning a quick stop into an opportunity for an unplanned treat. When products are visually appealing and easy to find, it enhances the shopping experience, reduces decision-making time, and increases the likelihood of a purchase. Maintaining proper temperature ensures the ice cream tastes as good as it looks, leading to customer satisfaction and repeat business.

In a convenience store, where quick decisions are key, maximizing visibility is paramount. An optimized display makes selection effortless, improving customer satisfaction and encouraging them to return. Furthermore, ensuring product quality through correct temperature control prevents spoilage and maintains the desired creamy texture, safeguarding reputation and ensuring every scoop delights. This also helps differentiate a store from competitors by offering a superior product experience.

Effective merchandising for ice cream transcends mere product presentation; it actively engages multiple senses and creates an experiential draw within the convenience store. The combination of optimal display temperature (ensuring ideal texture and feel), compelling visuals (colors, garnishes, lighting), and strategic placement (triggering impulse) transforms a passive display into an active “invitation to indulge”. This “marketing to the senses” directly influences customer desire and decision-making, turning a mundane purchase into a delightful moment and fostering a positive brand association that encourages repeat visits. It is about selling the experience of ice cream, not just the product. Additionally, designing displays with children in mind (e.g., lower viewing heights) is a strategic move, not just a thoughtful gesture. Children are powerful influencers in family purchasing decisions, especially for treats like ice cream. By making ice cream accessible and visually appealing to children, convenience stores can significantly increase family-based impulse purchases. This “kid-factor” translates into higher overall sales, as parents often yield to children’s requests, and it builds early brand loyalty with future consumers, representing a long-term investment in customer acquisition through the youngest demographic.

Here is how to implement this strategy:

• Strategic placement for impulse buys:
  • Position ice cream freezers near checkout counters, at the front of the store, or in other high-traffic areas where they are easily visible and can trigger impulse purchases.
  • Consider using countertop freezers near cash registers or top-loading novelty freezers that can be easily relocated to capitalize on high-traffic zones.
  • Design the store layout to naturally guide customers past the ice cream offerings before they reach the payment counter, improving flow and reducing decision time.
• Create visually appealing displays:
  • Arrange flavors attractively, grouping similar types together and using color contrast to create an eye-catching presentation.
  • Incorporate visual cues such as toppings, sauces, or garnishes (even artificial ones) to inspire customers to indulge and visualize their perfect treat.
  • Utilize brilliant LED lighting in glass door merchandisers to make products stand out and attract customers from a distance.
• Maintain proper temperature control:
  • Invest in freezers specifically designed for ice cream storage, which offer consistent temperatures. The ideal storage temperature is around -18°C (0°F) to prevent ice crystals and freezer burn.
  • For display cases, maintain a temperature between -14°C and -12°C (7°F to 10°F). This ensures the ice cream remains firm but scoopable, preventing it from melting too quickly.
  • Avoid frequent temperature fluctuations, which can negatively impact texture and quality.
• Use clear and compelling signage:
  • Clearly label each flavor and provide additional information, such as ingredients or dietary options.
  • Highlight promotional offers with large, bold text and high-contrast colors.
  • Incorporate catchy slogans that evoke emotion or humor, like “Scoop up happiness, one cone at a time” or “Life’s too short, eat the ice cream”.
  • Ensure signage aligns with brand identity, using consistent colors, fonts, and the store’s logo.

Purpose	Temperature Range	Why it Matters
Storage	-18°C (0°F) or slightly below	Prevents ice crystals, freezer burn, and maintains quality and texture. Essential for preserving flavor and freshness.
Display	-14°C to -12°C (7°F to 10°F)	Ensures ice cream remains firm but scoopable, preventing it from melting too quickly. Avoids frequent temperature fluctuations that degrade quality.

This table directly addresses a core operational concern, translating research data into an actionable standard. It helps owners ensure their ice cream always tastes its best, reinforcing positive customer experiences and protecting their investment in inventory. It is a simple yet powerful tool for quality control.

3. Curate a Winning Ice Cream Assortment

This strategy involves carefully selecting and stocking a diverse and appealing range of ice cream products, balancing popular classics with innovative trends and catering to various dietary preferences. It is about optimizing the “product mix” to meet customer demand.

A well-curated assortment caters to a wider array of customer tastes, ensuring there is something for everyone and encouraging new customers to explore offerings.¹⁷ Introducing trending or limited-edition flavors creates excitement and urgency, prompting customers to visit and try something new before it is gone. By offering variety, customers are encouraged to explore beyond their usual choices, potentially leading to higher basket sizes as they add different flavors or novelty items. This thoughtful selection also differentiates a store in a competitive market.

The ice cream market is mature but growing, with an increasing demand for premium, artisanal, non-dairy, and healthier options. By proactively meeting these evolving customer demands, a store is positioned as a relevant and desirable destination. A diverse assortment helps capture a larger share of the market, drive higher average transaction values, and build a reputation for variety and quality, which fosters long-term customer loyalty. It also allows a store to stay competitive by offering what larger stores or specialized shops might. In a competitive market, a convenience store’s ice cream assortment is no longer just about fulfilling a basic need; it is a powerful tool for differentiation and experience creation. By carefully curating a mix that balances familiar comfort (classics) with exciting novelty (trending, seasonal, global, savory flavors), stores can transform the act of buying ice cream into an exploratory and satisfying experience. This moves beyond transactional sales to building a reputation as a go-to destination for exciting and diverse ice cream options, which fosters customer loyalty and word-of-mouth marketing. The challenge is to avoid “menu fatigue” by regularly refreshing offerings while not overwhelming customers with excessive, irrelevant choices.

The effectiveness of an ice cream assortment hinges on data-driven agility. It is not a static decision but an ongoing process of monitoring sales metrics, gathering guest feedback, and being prepared to “pivot” when products do not resonate.²² This continuous refinement, especially with a “local-first approach” to cater to community preferences, allows convenience stores to optimize precious shelf space and ensure they are always offering the most appealing and profitable mix. This agile approach to category management, informed by real-time data and local insights, creates a virtuous cycle: better-fitting assortments lead to higher sales and customer satisfaction, which in turn provide more data for further optimization. This proactive, responsive strategy ensures the store remains highly relevant and competitive, maximizing revenue from every square inch of freezer space.

Here is how to implement this strategy:

• Balance classic favorites with trending innovations:
  • Ensure the store always stocks the top three classic flavors: vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry, as they continue to dominate preferences. These are consistent revenue drivers.
  • Integrate trending flavors that offer novelty and excitement. Consider “baked goods mash-ups” like Birthday Cake or Gooey Butter Cake ice cream, or “global delights” such as Taro, Ube, Horchata, or Yuzu-infused flavors.
  • Do not shy away from “savory scoops” or unexpected combinations like chili crisp peanut butter cup ²³ to generate buzz and appeal to adventurous palates.
• Include non-dairy, vegan, and healthier options:
  • Recognize the growing demand for plant-based milk alternatives and healthier options with less sugar or calories. Stocking these caters to a significant and growing segment of the market.
  • Ensure clear labeling for allergens and dietary preferences.
• Leverage seasonal or limited-edition flavors:
  • Introduce flavors that align with holidays or seasons. For example, pumpkin spice in fall, peppermint in winter, or tropical fruits in summer.
  • Limited-edition flavors create urgency and encourage quick purchases before they disappear.
• Utilize category management insights for optimal product depth and width:
  • Understand local customer preferences through sales data and feedback. A “localized assortment strategy” can significantly increase sales by catering to specific regional demands.
  • Balance “product width” (the range of different product lines) with “product depth” (the variety within each product line). For a convenience store, this often means a wide assortment of popular items, but perhaps less depth in niche categories, unless local demand dictates otherwise.
  • Be flexible and willing to test new products in a few stores before a wider rollout, and pivot quickly if something does not resonate.

Category	Description	Examples	Why It Matters
Classics	Core, consistently popular flavors that drive steady sales.	Vanilla, Chocolate, Strawberry.	These are universal crowd-pleasers and foundational revenue drivers, appealing to a broad customer base.
Baked Goods Mash-ups	Combinations of ice cream with elements of cakes, pies, or other baked goods.	Birthday Cake, Gooey Butter Cake, Strawberry Tres Leches.	Offer multi-textured, multi-flavored experiences that appeal to evolving tastes and create novelty.
Savory Scoops	Unexpected combinations incorporating savory ingredients.	Brie My Guest (cheese-flavored), Turkey Stuffing & Cranberry Sauce, Chili Crisp Peanut Butter Cup.	Generate buzz, attract adventurous palates, and position the store as innovative.
Global Delights	Flavors inspired by international cuisines.	Taro, Ube, Horchata, Yuzu, Matcha, Dulce de Leche Churro.	Cater to diverse demographics and offer unique, exotic experiences.
Dietary Alternatives	Options for specific dietary needs or preferences.	Non-dairy, vegan, lower sugar/calorie options.	Tap into growing market segments and demonstrate inclusivity, broadening customer reach.
Seasonal/Limited Edition	Flavors available for a short period, often tied to holidays or seasons.	Pumpkin Spice (fall), Peppermint (winter), Tropical Fruits (summer).	Create urgency, excitement, and encourage repeat visits to try new offerings before they are gone.

This table provides a strategic framework for ice cream inventory management, ensuring a balanced approach that maximizes appeal and profitability.

4. Elevate the Customer Experience with Sampling and Service

This strategy involves actively engaging customers through taste tests and exceptional staff interaction, transforming a transactional visit into a memorable experience.

Offering small samples of ice cream can be a powerful tool to engage customers and encourage them to try new flavors. This allows customers to experience the quality and taste firsthand, which can prompt them to make a purchase. This is particularly crucial when ice cream is expensive or flavors are unusual, as sampling reduces perceived risk for customers. Beyond sampling, staff play a vital role in customer satisfaction. Training them in product knowledge, suggestive selling, and active listening turns a transaction into exceptional service. This personal touch creates memorable brand interactions and fosters loyalty, making customers eager to return. The overall welcoming atmosphere contributes to the positive “vibe” that keeps people coming back.

Providing samples allows customers to “try before they buy,” building confidence in their purchase, especially with new or unique flavors. This direct sensory engagement can convert curiosity into sales. Furthermore, a well-trained and friendly staff elevates the entire shopping experience, making customers feel valued and understood. This fosters positive associations with the store, encouraging repeat business and word-of-mouth referrals, which are invaluable for long-term success. It also differentiates a store from competitors who might offer a less personalized or engaging experience.

Here is how to implement this strategy:

• Offer small, hygienic samples:
  • Provide tasting spoons and offer a selection of popular or unique flavors for sampling.
  • Ensure strict adherence to hygiene guidelines for sampling, including proper handwashing, use of single-use gloves or utensils, and maintaining correct temperatures for sampled food. All food contact surfaces must be cleaned and sanitized frequently.
  • Limit the amount of food preparation outside of approved kitchen spaces for sampling.
• Train staff for product knowledge and suggestive selling:
  • Equip employees with a deep understanding of different flavors, ingredients, and dietary options. Encourage them to try products themselves to gain firsthand experience.
  • Train staff in suggestive selling techniques, such as recommending complementary toppings (e.g., sprinkles, sauces, fruit) or suggesting an upgrade to a larger size for a small additional cost.
  • Encourage staff to listen attentively to customer preferences and offer personalized recommendations.
• Emphasize friendly greetings, active listening, and efficient service:
  • Train employees to greet every customer with a warm smile and a friendly “hello” upon entry, and to maintain professionalism through neat uniforms and positive body language.
  • Teach active listening techniques to understand customer questions or concerns, and how to paraphrase to confirm understanding.
  • Ensure employees are proficient with the point-of-sale (POS) system to process transactions quickly and accurately, acknowledging waiting customers to reassure them.
• Create a welcoming atmosphere:
  • Foster a comfortable and inviting store environment, ensuring cleanliness and organization.
  • Instill a customer-first mindset among employees, recognizing and rewarding those who consistently go above and beyond.

Table: Essential Staff Training for Ice Cream Sales

Training Area	Key Skills/Practices	Why it Matters
Product Knowledge	Deep understanding of flavors, ingredients, dietary options. Encouraging staff to try products.	Enables informed recommendations, builds customer confidence, and answers inquiries effectively.
Suggestive Selling	Recommending complementary items (toppings, cones), upsizing, personalized combos.	Increases average transaction value and enhances customer satisfaction by offering a complete experience.
Customer Service Fundamentals	Friendly greetings, active listening, positive body language, efficient transactions.	Creates a welcoming atmosphere, makes customers feel valued, and ensures a smooth, quick shopping experience.28
Problem Solving & Empathy	Remaining calm under pressure, identifying root causes, proactive solutions, putting oneself in customer’s shoes.	Handles complaints professionally, resolves issues effectively, and builds trust and loyalty, especially with challenging situations.
Hygiene & Safety	Proper handwashing, glove/utensil use, temperature control for samples, cleaning protocols.	Ensures food safety, maintains product quality, and builds customer trust in the store’s standards.

This table provides a comprehensive guide for training staff, highlighting the critical skills needed to enhance the ice cream sales experience and build customer loyalty.

5. Amplify Your Message with Smart Marketing and Loyalty Programs

This strategy involves using targeted communication channels and implementing customer retention initiatives to spread the word about ice cream offerings and encourage repeat business.

Smart marketing generates awareness and drives foot traffic to the store, especially during peak times like National Ice Cream Day. Social media provides the perfect platform to cultivate engaged communities and showcase ice cream’s photogenic qualities, generating excitement and drawing customers in. Loyalty programs, meanwhile, are highly effective for customer retention, which is often more profitable than customer acquisition. They incentivize repeat purchases and build emotional investment in the brand, turning casual buyers into loyal advocates.

Maximizing the impact of National Ice Cream Day requires amplifying the message across various channels. This holiday is a “seasonal marketing opportunity”. Effective marketing builds brand recognition and creates a consistent experience across touchpoints. Loyalty programs are crucial for building long-term relationships with customers, gathering valuable data, and ensuring sustained revenue beyond the holiday rush. Social media is not just for advertising; it is for community building and authentic marketing through user-generated content and interactive polls. This moves beyond passive advertising to active customer participation, leveraging the power of existing customers to promote the brand. Loyalty programs are evolving beyond simple points to personalized, tiered rewards that leverage data for deeper engagement. This builds emotional investment and real relationships, leveraging data for refinement. Local partnerships extend reach and relevance, while in-store signage reinforces the message.

Here is how to implement this strategy:

• Leverage social media for engaging content:
  • Consistently post “drool-worthy content” like slow-motion scoops, perfect cones, or the ice cream-making process.
  • Run interactive polls about flavor preferences, behind-the-scenes glimpses, or “Name That Flavor” contests.
  • Encourage user-generated content (UGC) by inviting customers to share photos with a branded hashtag, offering photo contests, or featuring their posts. This creates authentic marketing and community.
  • Use catchy captions and quotes related to ice cream and happiness.
  • Promote themed days or challenges, like a TikTok challenge for creating unique ice cream flavors.
• Utilize compelling in-store signage:
  • Design clear, readable signs with large, legible fonts and high color contrast to highlight promotions and new products.
  • Incorporate compelling visuals, such as high-resolution product images and universally recognized icons.
  • Use concise messaging and action-oriented language, highlighting key information with bold text or color.
  • Ensure all signage maintains a consistent visual style, aligning with the store’s brand identity and featuring the logo.
  • Strategically place signs at the entrance, endcap displays, or near checkout counters to guide customer flow and encourage impulse buys.
• Implement or enhance a loyalty program:
  • Offer achievable rewards that encourage repeat purchases, such as a free scoop after a certain number of purchases.
  • Consider tiered programs that offer increasing benefits for more loyal customers.
  • Provide special perks like birthday treats or exclusive member events.
  • Promote the loyalty program in-store, on the website, and through social media, making sign-up easy.
  • Utilize app-based loyalty programs for convenience, point tracking, and personalized offers.
• Explore local partnerships and cross-promotions:
  • Collaborate with local businesses (e.g., movie rental companies, pizza shops, car washes) for co-branded coupons or bundled promotions. This expands reach to new audiences.
  • Partner with local schools or community groups for fundraising events, donating a percentage of sales during a specific period. This builds community goodwill and attracts families.
  • Invite local food bloggers or influencers for free tastings in exchange for reviews or discounted codes for their followers.

Table: Social Media Content Ideas for National Ice Cream Day

Content Type	Description	Examples/Tips	Why it Matters
Visual Content	High-quality photos and videos showcasing ice cream.	Slow-motion scoops, perfect cones, ice cream-making process. Use visual focus of Instagram/TikTok.	Captures attention, makes ice cream look irresistible, and drives engagement online.
Interactive Posts	Content that encourages audience participation.	Polls about flavor preferences, “Name That Flavor” contests, quizzes.	Builds community, creates a sense of ownership, and increases anticipation for new products.
User-Generated Content (UGC)	Featuring customer photos and videos.	Encourage sharing with branded hashtags, run photo contests, repost customer content.	Provides authentic marketing, builds community, and showcases real enjoyment, which is highly influential.
Promotional Posts	Announcing deals and special offers.	“$1 Scoops on July 20th!”, “BOGO Pints This Week!”. Use clear, concise messaging.	Directly drives sales by informing customers about enticing offers and creating urgency.
Behind-the-Scenes	Glimpses into the store’s operations or staff.	How ice cream is stored, staff preparing a special sundae.	Builds transparency, humanizes the brand, and fosters a deeper connection with customers.
Quotes & Captions	Engaging text to accompany visuals.	“Life is better with sprinkles on top,” “I scream, you scream, we all scream for ice cream!”.	Adds personality, evokes emotion, and makes posts more shareable and memorable.
Themed Challenges	Creative, interactive activities for followers.	“Create Your Own Ice Cream Flavor” TikTok challenge with a special hashtag.	Leverages trending platforms, increases brand visibility, and generates widespread social engagement.
Local Partnerships	Promoting collaborations with other businesses.	Co-branded coupons, joint events with local pizzerias or movie theaters.	Expands reach to new audiences and reinforces community involvement.

This table offers a diverse range of social media content ideas, enabling convenience stores to create a dynamic and effective online presence for National Ice Cream Day and beyond.

The Bottom Line

National Ice Cream Day on July 20th is far more than just a date; it is a cultural celebration that presents a golden opportunity for convenience store owner/operators to significantly boost their ice cream sales and deepen customer engagement. By strategically implementing irresistible promotions, mastering the art of merchandising, curating a winning assortment, elevating the customer experience through exceptional service and sampling, and amplifying messages with smart marketing and loyalty programs, stores can transform this single day into a powerful catalyst for sustained growth.

Each of these 5 strategies, when executed thoughtfully, contributes to a holistic approach that not only drives immediate sales but also builds lasting customer relationships and strengthens brand presence in the local community. It is about creating memorable experiences, offering compelling value, and demonstrating a commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. So, embrace the sweet potential of National Ice Cream Day. By taking these actionable steps, convenience store owners can ensure that this year’s celebration is not just a success, but a true testament to their dedication to delighting customers, one scoop at a time.